What Is the Difference Between Pickling and Fermenting?
Quick Answer
Pickling usually preserves food in an acidic liquid such as vinegar, while fermentation relies on beneficial microorganisms producing acid naturally.
What’s Actually Happening?
Vinegar pickling introduces acidity directly. The strength of the vinegar, the amount of water and the proportions of other ingredients all affect the acidity of the finished product.
Fermentation uses microorganisms, often naturally present lactic acid bacteria, to convert sugars into acids. This creates the characteristic tangy flavour of foods such as sauerkraut and fermented cucumbers.
Although both methods can produce acidic foods, they are not interchangeable. A refrigerator pickle recipe is not automatically suitable for shelf storage.
How to Prevent or Fix It
For vinegar pickling, use a tested recipe and do not change the vinegar-to-water ratio. For fermentation, use a reliable recipe that specifies salt concentration, temperature, time and appropriate storage.
Keep refrigerated pickles refrigerated unless they have been processed using a tested canning method.
The Grounded Kitchen Tip
Think of pickling as adding acidity and fermentation as creating acidity. Both can preserve food, but they require different methods and controls.