How Can I Tell If Fish Is Fresh When Buying It?
The Quick Answer
Fresh fish should have a mild, clean smell, firm flesh and no obvious signs of drying or deterioration. Appearance varies by species, so smell, texture and proper refrigeration are more useful than colour alone.
What’s Actually Happening?
Fish is highly perishable. Its quality can deteriorate quickly if it is not kept cold, and some changes may not be obvious from appearance alone.
For whole fish, clear, plump eyes and bright gills can be useful signs. Fillets should look moist and firm, without excessive drying, discoloration or damaged edges.
A strong fishy, sour or ammonia-like smell is a warning sign. Fresh fish should smell mild and clean, not unpleasant.
Frozen fish can be an excellent choice. Modern freezing methods can preserve quality very well, and frozen portions may be more practical than fresh fish that has spent several days in storage or transport.
How to Prevent or Fix It
Buy fish from a reputable retailer and check that it is properly refrigerated or displayed on ice. Look for intact packaging on frozen products and avoid packages with signs of thawing and refreezing, such as excessive ice crystals or damaged seals.
Read labels carefully. “Previously frozen” does not mean poor quality; it simply tells you that the fish has been frozen before sale.
If fish has an unpleasant sour, rancid or ammonia-like odour, do not try to mask it with seasoning or cooking.
The Grounded Kitchen Tip
Don’t assume that fresh fish is always better than frozen. Properly frozen fish can be a convenient, high-quality choice.