What Is the Difference Between Natural and Dutch-Process Cocoa?
The Quick Answer
Natural cocoa is acidic, while Dutch-process cocoa has been treated to reduce its acidity. The difference matters most in recipes that use baking soda.
What’s Actually Happening?
Natural cocoa is made from cocoa solids that retain their natural acidity. Dutch-process cocoa is treated with an alkalizing agent, producing a darker colour and a smoother, less acidic flavour.
Baking soda needs an acidic ingredient to react and produce carbon dioxide, which helps baked goods rise. Natural cocoa can contribute some of that acidity.
Dutch-process cocoa does not provide the same acidic reaction. This means substituting one for the other can affect how a recipe rises, depending on its other ingredients and leaveners.
How to Make the Substitution
The safest approach is to use the type of cocoa specified in the recipe.
If a recipe calls for natural cocoa and relies on baking soda for its rise, replacing it with Dutch-process cocoa may affect the result. The reverse can also change the flavour and colour.
In recipes without chemical leaveners, such as many frostings, sauces and some brownies, the two types are often easier to exchange. The main difference will be flavour and colour.
The Grounded Kitchen Tip
Check the cocoa label before baking. If a recipe specifically says natural or Dutch-process, there is usually a reason. Don’t change the cocoa and the leavening agent at the same time unless you are following a tested conversion.